Tag: judge amanda hopkins
-
Appeals court confirms no bias by judge who formerly represented defendant
Colorado’s second-highest court ruled on Thursday that a Saguache County judge was not biased against a criminal defendant whose case she briefly worked on during her prior career as a public defender. A jury convicted Donald L. Garcia of motor vehicle theft in a trial presided over by Chief Judge Amanda C. Hopkins. On appeal,…
-
Colorado justices, 4-3, reject defendant’s challenge to biased judge
Although the Colorado Supreme Court acknowledged on Monday that a Saguache County judge was disqualified by law from presiding over a criminal case because she briefly represented the defendant before her appointment to the bench, a majority concluded there was nothing it could do because the defense knew about the conflict and stayed silent. By…
-
Colorado justices spar over need for new trial due to biased judge
When public defender Amanda C. Hopkins appeared in Saguache County District Court on April 17, 2018, her client failed to show up. The hearing was over in a matter of minutes. Records at the time did not document her brief substitution for the regular public defender assigned to the case. Three months later, Hopkins became…