Finger pushing
loader-image
weather icon 40°F


America’s immigration mess: Bad faith all around | SONDERMANN

Few issues are as complex and multi-faceted as that of immigration. Even fewer issues illustrate the magnitude of our political divide with bad faith to be found among the loudest voices on both poles.

The numbers are simply stunning. A veritable deluge of humanity approaches and crosses our southern border month after month, year after year.

Accurate counts are hard to come by. One commonly-cited statistic is that 3.8 million people entered the U.S. without permission from the start of the Biden administration through last September. Clearly, the months since have added substantially to that sum.

Of those 3.8 million individuals, a bit over 2.3 million were given Notices to Appear before an immigration court. That sheer volume assures that almost all such court dates will be infinitely far out in the unknown future. As to the other 1.5 million, they are referred to in some circles as “gotaways” who made it across the border without detection or contact.

As we get into this, it is important to note my background and bias. Both of my parents were Holocaust-era immigrants to America. I am beyond grateful for their good fortune even as their parents, my grandparents, had to leave other family members behind in Germany and to their fate.

Eighty-five years later, it is hard to find many historians or just regular Joes who make the case that the U.S. was overly generous with entry visas as Europe descended into unspeakable chaos. Instead, that was a time, not wholly unlike the current moment, of isolationist instincts and suspicion of foreigners.

Today, the root causes of global migration are more diffuse even as the political climate is similar. Nations are emptying out due to horrendous governance among other factors. Many individuals and families show up here with legitimate asylum requests. For them, the prospect of returning home is a death sentence. But vast numbers more come in search of opportunity while home offers only economic quicksand.

The paths migrants take to get here speak to their desperation. Lest we think this is a problem unique to the U.S., many European countries are living through even more intense immigration challenges.

Easy answers are fleeting. At a minimum, and acknowledging the limits on our carrying capacity, we can view those approaching our borders or already here with compassion and humanity.

Answers might be difficult but they are essential. Any fix, even partial, requires balance and a mature approach as opposed to the usual base-approving soundbites and shibboleths.

Sadly, neither political party seems remotely up to that task. In this dance of dysfunction, both Republicans and Democrats know how to tango.

Led by their former president and presumptive nominee, with his distinct eau de xenophobia, Republicans put forward the fanciful notion of hermetically sealing the border while rounding up a few million residents, mostly living in the shadows while working their butts off, and putting them in a giant caravan heading south.

Sure, and will you manage that in a week or should we spot you two?

Donald Trump, never lacking a knack for finding a hot button he can inflame, now urges his congressional sycophants to ditch any bipartisan deal in favor of keeping the issue fully alive as a wedge for November.

Why try to fix a problem when there are attack ads to be run?

If Republicans exhibit a deficit of compassion, Democrats are paralyzed by an excess of it to go along with a fundamental misread of the core demands of national sovereignty.

Assuredly, there are global forces at play in this mass migration and Joe Biden is not solely at fault. But he is the guy in charge; and the one seemingly overmatched.

If Biden was intent on border security, why did he put Kamala Harris in charge of it early in his term? How did that work out?

In many corners of the Democratic Party, the very phrase, “border security,” is verboten. Rather, with more heart than head, and with so-called global citizenship superseding national interests, the attitude is best captured by the frequently heard sentiment, “No person is illegal.”

As a matter of inherent self-worth, of course that is the case. But as a matter of law, not so much. If you entered the country without complying with legal procedure, you are here illegally. There is no cute, semantic absolution.

Per a recent article in these pages, Denver Mayor Mike Johnston, lacking neither smarts nor ambition, is reluctant in the extreme to talk of “border security.” He recognizes that the idea itself is held in disregard by dominant elements of his party.

This rhetorical avoidance comes even in the face of the migrant crisis with which Denver and other Colorado communities are contending. Johnston, himself, is talking of a $180 million obligation for Denver taxpayers if the crisis continues unabated throughout the year. That could result in cuts of 10 to 15 percent in departmental budgets across the board. We’re not talking pocket change.

Then there is the matter of what critics call “sanctuary cities” and more self-righteous types refer to as “welcoming communities.” Whatever the nomenclature, a refusal to enforce applicable laws is a form of nullification.

If these were southern towns calling themselves sanctuaries from civil rights laws, I wonder what the response would be.

In 1996, not infinitely long ago, the Democratic Party platform touted President Clinton’s first-term accomplishments in controlling the border and stated, “Today’s Democratic Party believes we must remain a nation of laws. We cannot tolerate illegal immigration and we must stop it.”

A headline in Reason magazine some time back captured the evolution of the elite Democratic viewpoint since then: “From anger to apathy to amnesty.”

Is it any wonder that Democrats are hemorrhaging votes among the working-class electorate? Even a majority of Latino voters are put off, instead favoring policies that reward those who wait in line and play by the rules.

Were either party capable of wisdom and compromise, an intelligent immigration policy would include four basics.

It would provide the resources and direction to meaningfully enforce laws and secure entry points. It would distinguish between legitimate asylees and others with aspirations for a better life but without the real threat of political persecution.

It would not simply process the masses showing up at the border but would strategically prioritize those with specialized skills who would add exceptional value to our country.

Finally, it would impose some additional burden on immigrant newcomers. For generations, including in my parents’ time, the expectation was assimilation. Now, in too many circles, that idea is itself controversial. It has been largely replaced by “integration” as the politically-correct word.

Simply, no. America is a nation of immigrants. Wave after wave of those who have come, legally, have provided far more benefit than weight. But it was their desire and the country’s requirement that they embrace America, give it their primary allegiance and weave into the national fabric.

In my foreign travels, I have yet to place a phone call and been given the option of, “Press 2 for English.”

Eric Sondermann is a Colorado-based independent political commentator. He writes regularly for ColoradoPolitics and the Gazette newspapers. Reach him at EWS@EricSondermann.com; follow him at @EricSondermann

Cots were set up in an emergency shelter for people arriving from the southern U.S. border at a Denver rec center Dec. 13, 2022. The crisis on the border has been spilling over into America’s interior – to cities like Denver, Chicago and New York.   
The denver gazette

b473d6b4-bfc4-11ee-963b-bf3fe98a6464

View Original Article | Split View

Reporter


Welcome Back.

Streak: 9 days i

Stories you've missed since your last login:

Stories you've saved for later:

Recommended stories based on your interests:

Edit my interests