ACLU questions panhandling law
A decision made in June by Manitou Springs City Council to table discussion on the constitutionality of the city’s panhandling ordinance has come home to roost.Nathan Butler, known as “Nada” to many in Manitou Springs, was charged with panhandling on August 22 near Soda Springs Park after recent mayoral candidate Nancy Barnes alleged she had seen Butler attempting to sell necklaces without a business license. Butler, a resident of Texas visiting Manitou for the summer, insisted that he had not been panhandling, only playing his guitar, but even if he had been soliciting, he should not have been given a citation.“It seemed like a liberal town with a lot of artists and musicians,” Butler said. “But behind that curtain there were a group of people who weren’t comfortable with that and were trying to change that. I felt like the reason I was ticketed was an attempt to run me out of town, but what it did in actuality was keep me longer.”Butler said he had planned to stay in Manitou for a month, but because of his impending court date, he stayed more than three months. Running short of funds, Butler returned to Texas and contacted the American Civil Liberties Union of Colorado, which took up his case.ACLU legal director Mark Silverstein researched Manitou’s panhandling ordinance. He discovered that city attorney Jeff Parker had advised council earlier this year that the current ordinance might be unconstitutional and should be revised. A letter was sent to the Manitou city prosecutor asking that the charges against Butler, as well as any other pending panhandling charges, be dropped. Charges against Butler were dropped on Friday and Silverstein said the ACLU had submitted an open records request for all other pending panhandling cases.“I’ve seen a lot of attempts to regulate and outlaw panhandling,” Silverstein said. “But this is probably the most unconstitutional one I’ve ever seen. It applies everywhere in the city, whether on public or private property. And the definition of panhandling is so broad that it applies if you ask your friend for a quarter to put in the parking meter; that’s panhandling according to the ordinance. It’s a crime.”The question of the ordinance’s constitutionality came to council’s attention earlier this year when The Gazette printed an editorial questioning whether having street performers in Manitou, who are currently vetted through the Chamber of Commerce, was even legal under the town’s current panhandling ordinance.Councilwoman Aimee Cox examined the panhandling ordinances in Denver, Boulder, Fort Collins and Colorado Springs. With her direction, a new ordinance was drafted to prohibit “aggressive soliciting,” which included provisions like not soliciting within 20 feet of an ATM or as a person is entering or exiting their car. The ordinance passed unanimously at the first reading, but at its second reading on June 2, many local merchants showed up to express their displeasure with a change they saw as bad for business.“I felt they were just misinformed about the ordinance and what the restrictions were,” Cox said. “They felt that it was basically allowing people to come into our community and panhandle, which clearly was not the case. I think council prudently chose to put the final verdict on hold until we could talk to the merchants further. But my contention was, I wanted to do this at a date certain because I felt there was a sense of urgency with this. I don’t think Manitou wants to be in a position where we’re violating anyone’s civil rights, ever — certainly not with our reputation for being a welcoming tolerant community.”On Monday, Cox said she thought the issue was important enough for her to ask that it be placed on the work session agenda for council’s Tuesday night budget meeting.“We have to balance civil rights with commerce,” she said. “Manitou’s got problems, but we’re not Gotham City. Crime hasn’t run amok in our town.”
Mark Silverstein Photo by
Nancy Barnes Photo by
Nathan Butler (Nada) Photo by





