Finger pushing
loader-image
weather icon 28°F


Many Colorado Springs-area students opt out of PARCC tests

In some Colorado classrooms, more students didn’t take the state’s new English and math tests than did.

A lot of students refused.

None of the 29 11th-graders at Edison Academy in Yoder took the English exams, and at James Irwin Charter School, in Harrison School District 2, just nine of the 94 11th-graders participated.

2015 school-by-school PARCC scores

The Colorado Department of Education on Friday released scores and participation rates for exams created through a multi-state partnership known as the Partnership for Assessment of Readiness for College and Careers.

Students in grades 3-11 in Colorado’s 178 public schools took the tests this spring.

Refusals could be a problem for what is supposed to be baseline-setting scores on which to measure students’ academic progress in subsequent years.

“There’s no way we can look at anything programmatically, particularly at the high school, where the lion’s share of our refusals were,” said Patricia Urban, assessment coordinator and director of elementary student services for Manitou Springs School District 14.

The tests are different from previous standardized assessments; they are aligned to new and tougher academic standards designed to gauge how on-track students are to enter college or a career after graduation.

But parents objected to the slate of lengthier and more rigorous tests, citing concerns over federal intrusion into the state-run public education system, data-privacy issues, the amount of classroom time devoted to preparing for the tests, the value of the exams and resistance to Common Core State Standards.

Statewide, about 10 percent of students refused to do the assessments.

Participation varied greatly among the Pikes Peak region’s 17 school districts. In Manitou Springs D-14, 38 percent of all students did not take the math test, while in Widefield School District 3, less than 1 percent of students didn’t show up on test day.

Refusal rates for math ranged from nearly 70 percent in the region’s smallest school district, Edison 54-JT, to just a few refusals in Cripple Creek-Victor RE-1.

“Very few staff, including myself, have confidence in these tests,” said Les Lindauer, RE-1 superintendent. “We do not make any changes based just on these scores. We rely much more on assessments that are closer to the instruction in the classroom.”

Some education officials, however, view the less-than-perfect representation of student participation as one of those turning lemons into lemonade lessons.

“We often try to make it all about how good the teacher is or how great a school is, so this forces us to see how these scores can be applicable to individual students rather than making accountability the primary reason to use these scores,” said Eric Mason, director of assessment for Colorado Springs School District 11, the region’s largest with about 28,000 students.

What about pupils who didn’t test?

“That’s OK, too,” Mason said. “We rely on knowledge from the professionals, the teachers, to improve instruction to meet students’ needs.”

Across the board, refusals were highest among older students. At Cheyenne Mountain High School, for example, 283 of 315 11th-graders did not participate in the English exams.

“Some of the older students felt like they didn’t have any skin in the game. These scores were not valuable personally to them,” Mason said.

The refusal movement started in more affluent schools that have lower numbers of low-income students and minority students but then fanned out to a broader spectrum.

“It spread quite quickly and became balanced among economically advantaged and disadvantaged students, hitting a stride in 10th and 11th grade, where we did not even eke out 50 percent participation in language arts or math,” Mason said.

In November, the U.S. Department of Education approved a waiver request from Colorado’s State Board of Education not to penalize school districts that did not meet the federal testing requirement of 95 percent participation – which in the past had not been difficult for schools to meet.

Thus, federal funding will not be affected, districts’ accreditation will not be impacted for this school year, and student test scores from last year cannot count toward teacher evaluations this year.

Changes at the federal and state levels will further influence testing going forward.

On Thursday, President Barack Obama signed into law a bill that overhauls K-12 education and returns more power to the states, including accountability in testing.

And after a task force studied the state’s testing environment and prepared a report showing overall dissatisfaction with the system, state lawmakers made several adjustments for this school year.

Social studies, science, English and math tests, which will be given April 11-29, will be shorter in duration and administered only in one part, instead of two. Eleventh-graders will take a college-entrance exam for their test, and 10th-graders also will have a different test.

Good news, said Kristy Rigdon, coordinator of curriculum, instruction and assessment for Falcon School District 49.

“Legislative changes will result in devoting fewer days and hours to taking these tests this year,” she said. “The changes also will mean less testing fatigue and more high-quality instructional time for students.”

Falcon D-49 Superintendent Peter Hilts said that should lead toward “increased mastery of content across the board.”

Regarding PARCC scores, results in local districts tended to mirror those of previous versions of standardized assessments, with historically high-performing schools also coming out on top in this rendition.

Scores are lower, though, than in the past, which was expected because of the new and harder format.

There are five levels of performance: did not meet expectations; partially met expectations; approached expectations; met expectations; and exceeded expectations. Scores in the latter two mean students are performing on track for career- and college-readiness.

Since so few students took the tests in some schools and grade levels, there were no exact percentages in the region of students who met or exceeded expectations for almost 20 percent of the English scores and 27 percent of the math scores.

Of the schools that had exact scores in English, only about 30 percent of those scores had half or more students either meeting or exceeding expectations. The number is 22 percent for math scores.

Challenger Middle School in Academy School District 20 posted the best math scores in the region in algebra, with 92.6 percent meeting or exceeding expectations.

Principal Tony Scott said the school made a concerted effort to realign curriculum to the new state academic standards, with teachers meeting weekly to discuss how it’s going. As a result, math performance has steadily improved in recent years.

“We’ll disaggregate the data to look at strength areas and areas in which we need improvements,” he said. “Even though we’re excited about our achievement, we look forward to the time when the state is able to provide us with the very important growth scores.”

Growth scores measuring individual student progress will be available starting next year.

Some local educators said it was apparent that some students who took the PARCC tests did not try their best. Others noted that computer problems hampered test-taking. For the first time, students did the tests on computers and not using pencil and paper.

“No class or testing situation went without kids being completely kicked off and starting over at least once or more than once within the assessment window,” said Manitou Springs’ Urban. “We don’t know what impact those technology glitches might have had on kids’ concentration and their abilities to stay with a long exam.”

The expectation that participation rates will be higher next spring when the tests roll around again is common among some school leaders, but not all.

Urban said in her district, parents already have been asking “if their opt-out letter for last year is good for this year.”

“There’s only 1,500 students in our whole district, so it doesn’t take much of a groundswell to bring everybody along,” she said. “We have a strong group of folks who are excited about what’s happening day to day in the classroom and really find this form of state testing an intrusion. This was the straw that broke the camel’s back. But they don’t want anything to penalize the district, so if we can turn the message around and are clear where the state is going down the road, I think we’ll be able to encourage parents to rejoin us.”

–

Gazette reporter Maria St. Louis-Sanchez contributed to this story.

Jason Wood (The Denver Post)
Jason Wood (The Denver Post)


Welcome Back.

Streak: 9 days i

Stories you've missed since your last login:

Stories you've saved for later:

Recommended stories based on your interests:

Edit my interests