Finger pushing
loader-image
weather icon 39°F


Conflicting competency reports delay case of accused UCCS shooter

The status of the case of the University of Colorado Colorado Springs student accused of killing two individuals in a dorm room earlier this year now remains uncertain after a competency hearing was scheduled on Friday morning.

Nicholas Jordan, 25, is accused of shooting and killing Celie Rain Montgomery, 26, of Pueblo, and Samuel Knopp, 24, of Parker, in the early morning hours of Feb. 16.

Jordan and Knopp were roommates and students at UCCS, according to previous reporting from The Gazette. Jordan’s arrest affidavit states that he had made a death threat against Knopp over taking out the trash, and that campus security and housing had recorded multiple complaints about Jordan prior to the shooting.

On Friday Jordan appeared in court for a status conference where Judge David Shakes informed the court that a competency hearing was now needed after the prosecution’s expert found Jordan competent to proceed.

In April, Shakes announced that the first competency evaluation, performed by the Colorado Mental Health Institute at Pueblo, found Jordan incompetent to proceed. The prosecution then requested for a second evaluation by an expert unaffiliated with CMHIP.

A competency hearing is scheduled when two conflicting competency reports are filed to the court regarding the same defendant. The two experts who conducted the conflicting reports will appear in court to testify as to their findings and a judge will make the final determination on if the defendant is mentally competent or not to stand trial.

If Shakes finds Jordan is competent to proceed, a preliminary hearing will be scheduled to determine if there is probable cause or not to bind over the six charges faced by Jordan. If Shakes finds Jordan incompetent to proceed, the case will be stalled indefinitely until Jordan is restored to competency through mental health services.

Competency hearings can often lead to contentious court hearings.

Last year a competency hearing was held for Tyrek Williams, 23, who is accused of beating Andrew Dominguez, 56, to death at 7-Eleven in 2022. Due to conflicting competency reports, a competency hearing was scheduled where Judge Frances Johnson ruled that the evaluation finding Williams competent held more weight and ruled him competent to proceed with his case.

Since then, Williams’ attorneys have been adamant that their client — who has appeared to every court hearing handcuffed to a wheelchair and wearing a muzzle — should be receiving mental health restoration services. At his most recent hearing Williams’ attorneys pleaded not guilty by reason of insanity on his behalf, due to a lack of communication with their client over the past year.

Regardless of the findings of Shakes at Jordan’s upcoming competency hearing, a lengthy delay in the case appears to be unavoidable. Due to scheduling conflicts with the attorneys and the two experts, Shakes was unable to schedule the competency hearing until Aug. 16.

“A three-month delay concerns me a little bit,” Shakes said in court. “That’s a long time to have no progress on the case.”

Shakes stated he hopes to potentially schedule the hearing sooner if the prosecution and defense can agree on a new date.

Jordan’s second case where he is accused of assaulting a deputy in the El Paso County jail over a dispute regarding cleaning supplies also remains on hold pending the results of the competency hearing.

Jordan remains in custody at the El Paso County jail on a $5 million bond for the double homicide case, and a $10,000 bond on the assault case.

Nicholas Jordan makes his first appearance at the El Paso County Combined Courts on Friday, Feb. 23, in Colorado Springs. Jordan was arrested Monday morning, three days after he allegedly shot and killed two people in Crestone House, a dormitory on the University of Colorado-Colorado Springs campus. (Parker Seibold, the gazette)
Nicholas Jordan makes his first appearance at the El Paso County Combined Courts on Friday, Feb. 23, in Colorado Springs. Jordan was arrested Monday morning, three days after he allegedly shot and killed two people in Crestone House, a dormitory on the University of Colorado-Colorado Springs campus. (Parker Seibold, the gazette)
Tags


Welcome Back.

Streak: 9 days i

Stories you've missed since your last login:

Stories you've saved for later:

Recommended stories based on your interests:

Edit my interests