Colorado Springs 7-Eleven homicide case drags on
The attorneys representing the Colorado Springs man accused of killing a man by striking him more than 100 times at a 7-Eleven informed the court Thursday that a sanity evaluation being conducted on their client won’t be complete until 2025.
Tyrek Williams, 23, faces one count of first-degree murder and two violent crime sentence enhancers for allegedly striking and killing Andrew Dominguez, 56, in a Colorado Springs 7-Eleven in February 2022.
Williams, who refused transport to court Thursday, will not go to trial until at least 2025 after his attorney reported to the court that the earliest the sanity evaluation being conducted on their client will be complete is Jan. 31.
At Williams’ last hearing in April, his attorneys opted to enter a plea of not guilty by reason of insanity on Williams’ behalf, due to his refusal to speak to his lawyers, social workers and law enforcement at the El Paso County jail.
Williams’ mental health has been at the center of his case since his arrest in 2022.
According to previous reporting from The Gazette, Judge Frances Johnson heard testimony in December from prosecution and defense experts with competing opinions on Williams’ competency and mental health.
According to the defense’s expert, Williams had a family history of “thought disorders” like schizophrenia. Testimony from jail therapists also made mention of the possibility of Williams having experienced “internal stimuli,” like hearing voices, during visits with staff.
The prosecution called a psychologist contracted with the Colorado Mental Health Hospital in Pueblo, the state’s coordinator for competency evaluations. Williams’ evaluation was completed in March of last year, reflecting the state’s long-term backlog of court-ordered mental health evaluations.
The state’s psychologist said that their evaluation of Williams pointed strongly to a diagnosis of antisocial personality disorder, which would not provide cause for Williams to be found incompetent.
The Colorado Mental Health Hospital evaluator downplayed the reported symptoms of more serious mental issues, alleging that Williams might have been faking symptoms in order to receive better jail accommodations. She also testified that Williams appeared “rational” and “reasonable” during a 1½-hour-long interview.
Ultimately, Johnson ruled on the side of the state evaluator, declaring Williams competent to proceed despite continued objections from the defense.
Williams’ attorney John Winegar again made it clear that he did not agree with the court’s decision to find Williams competent to proceed.
“I still believe he is incompetent to proceed.”
Winegar said that he still has not spoken with his client in more than a year, and added that he sees “no other way forward” than to just wait for the sanity evaluation to be complete by experts at Colorado Mental Health Hospital.
Williams at his last several court dates appeared handcuffed to a wheelchair with a spit guard covering his mouth. At those court dates Williams refused to speak to the judge even when directly addressed.
In addition to the homicide case, Williams also has 12 open criminal cases in El Paso County. The bulk of those cases are assault against a peace officer cases taking place from inside the El Paso County jail after Williams was arrested for allegedly killing Dominguez. Since Williams was last in court he has picked up two new assault cases; one filed in June and the other filed on Saturday.
Johnson expressed concern and frustration with Williams continuing to pick up new assault charges while in custody.
“(Williams) is supposed to be in his jail cell the majority of his days, how does this keep happening,” Johnson asked the prosecution.
“I can ask the jail and see, but at the end of the day there’s nothing I can do to make the defendant stop assaulting people,” prosecutor Jessica Kiel said in response.
With a lack of items to address until the completion of Williams’ sanity evaluation, the court set Feb. 6, 2025, as his next scheduled court date. Kiel said that when lead prosecutor Jennifer Viehman returns they may file a motion with the court that could require a court date before Feb. 6.
Williams remains in custody at the El Paso County jail on a no-bond hold.






