Den instincts, positive reinforcement can aid in crate training dogs
PETacular Magazine is a quarterly Gazette publication featuring stories sponsored by pet businesses and organizations in the Pikes Peak region.
You’ve heard the arguments: crates are cruel and should not be used; you must crate train every dog. So, to crate or not to crate? The answer lies in how a crate is used.
Many dogs can adapt well to using a crate, which can be traced back to the canine’s history as a den animal. Den behavior allows a dog to feel secure and happy in a den-type environment, like a crate. However, crating can become a negative experience when misused.
When crating your dog, it is important to introduce the habit gradually. As you first teach a dog to like a crate, be sure to avoid isolating your dog while it’s in the crate. For example, crate the dog in a high-traffic room in the home or a space in which you can hang out with it for a few hours. After the dog gets used to its family being around, you can begin to leave the dog alone. Soon, it won’t mind staying in a crate when you aren’t immediately available.
Crates are often misused as a form of punishment. Reminiscent of a child being told to go to his or her room after acting out, this technique is not an effective tool for training pets. A dog will always need a positive association with its crate – even if your dog knows it did something you disapprove of, don’t put it in a crate for punishment.
I had a foster named Shilo who hated crates because a previous owner had put her in a crate after being punished. Shilo quickly associated the crate with negativity and never felt secure inside a crate. If I offered a treat to try and coax her into the crate, she’d run off. If I did manage to get her in the crate, she’d fret the entire time. Eventually, through systematic desensitization, Shilo not only got over her fear of the crate, she began to go into the crate and “hang out” on her own accord. Though it does take work, dogs can change a negative attitude about crates into a positive one.
Crates can be handy when a dog is too young to be trusted alone inside a house. I don’t recommend leaving a dog less than a year old unattended inside a house. Some are tenacious chewers before their first birthdays, and I’ve heard too many stories of young dogs dying after chewing through electrical cords. Additionally, dogs under age 1 are experiencing the most intense part of their adolescence. That can result in destructive behaviors when the dog roams the house without guidance. Using a crate can often keep these unwanted habits from developing.
While it isn’t a wrong to crate a dog inside the house while you are gone, dog owners need to avoid over-crating. How much is too much varies from dog to dog. Some dogs will tolerate many hours in a crate, while others will not. If you have a more active dog that you need to crate, make sure you give the dog plenty of exercise before asking for extra crating time.
Crates can be used as house-training tools, however, you need to mind a few rules. Trainers will caution you to not select too large of a crate, which invites a dog to sleep in one end and potty in the other. The best-sized crate is bigger than the immediate sleeping area, but not by much. A crate more than twice the sleeping area size is too large. However, a dog needs room to sleep in a crate away from any accident it might have. Even reliably house-trained dogs can end up with unexpected distress. If the dog has no choice but to lay in a mess too many times, the experience can result in a dog not trying to keep the crate clean. Dogs that chronically mess in a crate require specialized training to re-establish their natural den habits of keeping their sleeping area clean.
Whether you are a fan of crating or not, I believe all dogs need to be crate trained, as many eventually need to stay overnight at a veterinarian clinic. Crate-trained dogs will be less distressed in this situation, while dogs that have never been crate will be fearful of not only an unfamiliar place, but also of being trapped in a confined area.
I once owned a beloved Jack Russell Terrier named Cookie. One day, on a walk, a large dog that had escaped its pen rushed up and grabbed my dog in his mouth. If I didn’t have a leash on the dog, she’d have been lost forever. Cookie need to spend the night at an emergency vet hospital. Once home, she’d sometimes awake from my lap startled and run to her crate. She stayed there until she felt safe enough to come out. Psychologically, she did recover from that attack, and I think having a crate that felt safe to hide in for a while helped. Crating can be a wonderful tool to make life easier on both you and your dog.
Peggy Swager is a dog trainer and behaviorist. Her newest book is “Rescue Your Dog from Fear.” For more resources and information on crate training, visit www.peggyswager.com.







