‘Messiah’ Parts II and III performed at First United Methodist
As a minister of music, James Steven Harter has conducted George Frideric Handel’s “Messiah” more than 40 times over the course of his career. The three-part English-language oratorio, composed almost 275 years ago, is still an audience hit today, especially around Christmas.
When he steps up to lead the Chancel Choir, orchestra and soloists at First United Methodist Church in a performance of Handel’s best-known work on March 22, Harter will be in relatively fresh territory, though.
“It’s only my second time conducting a production of Messiah that included Part III,” he said. “The last time that the Chancel Choir at First United Methodist Church sang it was in 1994. Certainly the Colorado Springs Chorale has done it since, but not in our church. Part III has some of the best music of all of ‘Messiah.'”
Why the lack of exposure for Part III? It may have something to do with familiarity and tradition.
The oratorio, with scriptural text from the King James Bible, presents the story of Christ’s life in three chapters, beginning with the virgin birth and ending with Christ’s glorification in heaven. Handel never meant the work as a piece of Christmas music, and in fact the first public performance was during Lent in April 1742, at a concert hall in Dublin. Holiday associations changed forever in 1818 when the work premiered stateside, however.
“During Handel’s lifetime, ‘Messiah’ was never done at Christmas time, but the first time it was performed in the United States was in Boston on Christmas Day. That’s probably why it stuck,” said Harter, who conducts a December performance of Parts I and II. “Now it’s typically done at Christmas time in this country and that’s what people associate it with.”
Another reason for the partial performances? Time.
Most Christmas holiday performances include the first two parts of “Messiah,” if not just Part I, with its popular “Hallelujah” chorus.
“It would probably be three hours or more to do all three parts, so it’s usually broken up because of the length,” said Helen Bagherian, who handles concert promotions for the church. “In Europe, people will sit through it. We Americans will get antsy.”






