Finger pushing
loader-image
weather icon 37°F


GUEST COLUMN: A peaceful solution to the marriage debate

Though she is pro-choice, Supreme Court Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg decried the “heavy-handed judicial activism” regarding abortion in Roe v. Wade. Judges in the current debate over marriage are again disrespecting the people by denying sufficient input from them, thus risking another never-ending culture war. Fortunately, there is a peaceful solution.

In April, Mozilla CEO Brendan Eich was pressured into resigning for donating $1,000 six years previously to a cause seeking to preserve marriage as male/female. In a July Gazette column, Democratic candidate for Colorado attorney general, Don Quick, presented his opinions favoring same-sex marriage as though they were the only opinions any decent person could hold. Recently, after hearing people disparage me for my support of traditional marriage, a relative who silently supports it urged me to stop voicing my opinion.

In the 1960s, a frequent response for proving one’s manhood when propositioned by someone of the same sex was to mock him or even become violent; I simply declined and remained cordial. In the 1971 American Psychiatric Association meeting in Washington, D.C., a slender, fragile appearing homosexual man named Franklin Kameny interrupted the proceedings to plead for “Homosexuality” to be removed from our diagnostic manual. I greatly respected his courage. More recently, I helped two women repair their romantic relationship.

How, then, has it come to pass that people like myself, who simply want to preserve marriage as male-female, are now frequently called names (homophobic, bigoted) and cast out (Eich) by members of a group for whose trials we have sincerely felt? How tragic and ironic that many people with same-sex attraction who were once intimidated into the closet are now doing the same to people who differ with them regarding marriage. While suffering often leads victims to seek revenge, bullying when we “dislike the unlike” wasn’t right then and isn’t right now.

It’s as if: “You told us to shut up because our sexual orientation was shameful. Well, now we’re telling you to shut up because your orientation regarding marriage is shameful.” Out of caring, however, shouldn’t we speak up when we see former victims adopting the odious traits of their victimizers?

Good people can differ. What’s wrong with calling same-sex formal commitments “unions” and continuing to call opposite-sex formal commitments “marriage”? We’ve established that having same-sex attraction has no relevance to one’s character. Why does my supporting legalization of same-sex unions as a just, compassionate, and peaceful solution disparage my character?

Answer: Fear that acknowledging differences in what sex one is attracted to will lead to resumed persecution. Indeed, history is filled with persecution of people who are different. However, denying that male-female psychological differences exist and matter is not a solution.

Two ways of dealing with differences between people are:

– Eliminate differences, e.g., create one mixed race; make everyone’s earning ability and income roughly the same; intimidate everyone into saying that male-female psychological differences make no difference.

Aristotle: “The worst form of inequality is to try to make unequal things equal.” Eliminating differences so as to make unequal things equal requires the use of intimidation and force – new persecution to “remedy” past persecution. Diversity and truth become victims. Males and females have significant psychological differences; indeed, they’re the rationale for sex change surgery to address “feeling like a woman trapped in a man’s body.”

Is there any doubt that, even if social and anatomical engineering could one day eliminate most differences between people, we would still find reasons to persecute? And do we think that whatever totalitarian force could succeed in making us think and be the same will provide something better than what we have now?

– The Bible’s “love the stranger.” Many of the stranger’s differences have advantages. Monogamy’s difference from polygamy led to less jealousy and thus more family harmony. Psychological differences between males and females allow the child’s exposure to richly diverse mentalities that usually exist between mothers and fathers. A child’s having parents of the opposite sex and also not from the same nuclear family (no incest) teaches the child how to understand and love a person who is different. The above differences are significant and valuable enough to societal well-being to warrant a separate word that embodies them: marriage.

Loving the stranger is the way humans can best deal with differences. The other option, eliminating differences, leaves us with no one very different to love. Thus, we don’t really learn how to love.

When love exits and animosity fills the vacuum, peace beware. To end the war about marriage and preserve a peaceful, civilized culture, we must seek to understand and treat with dignity those with whom we differ.

–

Deane Shore Berson, M.D., is a psychiatrist who has lived in the Pikes Peak area since 1974.

 

Tags


Welcome Back.

Streak: 9 days i

Stories you've missed since your last login:

Stories you've saved for later:

Recommended stories based on your interests:

Edit my interests