OUR VIEW: Clean water activists absent on solar (Poll)
Where are the opponents of oil and gas when we need them?
Whenever City Council contemplates oil and gas production on annexed undeveloped land, protesters known as “fractivists” stage bullhorn-and-sign demonstrations outside of City Hall. They profess a holy obsession with clean water. The highly regulated practice of hydraulic fracturing could, they tell us, conceivably pollute fresh water. They don’t even like that hydraulic fracturing involves consumption of water. They ignore expert testimony that says hydraulic fracturing has an enviably clean environmental record. They dismiss arguments that hydraulic fracturing takes place far below the water table. When all else fails, they invoke global warming arguments against oil and gas.
Even those who disagree should admire their evangelical passion for water. It is, after all, such a good cause. We should assume these activists will defend our water from anything that might cause it harm.
So we ask: Where were these water warriors when City Council imposed on ratepayers the burden of rate hikes to subsidize tens of millions in solar panels?
Surely, the fractivists know about the environmental risks involved with solar.
“Fueled partly by billions in government incentives, the industry is creating millions of solar panels each year and, in the process, millions of pounds of polluted sludge and contaminated water,” states an Associated Press story distributed in February.
Here’s more:
“To dispose of the material, the companies must transport it by truck or rail far from their own plants to waste facilities hundreds and, in some cases, thousands of miles away.
“The fossil fuels used to transport that waste, experts say, is not typically considered in calculating solar’s carbon footprint, giving scientists and consumers who use the measurement to gauge a product’s impact on global warming the impression that solar is cleaner than it is.”
AP tried to account for the sludge and contaminated water produced by California’s 41 solar manufacturers but found the state had records on only 17 of them. The 17 reported 46.5 million pounds of sludge and contaminated water, containing carcinogenic cadmium, from 2007 through 2010. The AP, and the state of California, have no idea what became of the sludge and contaminated water from the majority of producers for which the state has no records. We have no assurance the sludge and cadmium water, intrinsic to solar manufacturing, didn’t end up in waterways. It had to go somewhere.
Now that Council has forced residents of Colorado Springs to fund the barely-regulated solar industry, fractivists should demand answers.
An April 2 report in the Stanford Report — written to defend solar — begins with this:
“The rapid growth of the solar power industry over the past decade may have exacerbated the global warming situation it was meant to soothe, simply because most of the energy used to manufacture the millions of solar panels came from burning fossil fuels.”
And this:
“The energy used to produce solar panels is intense. The initial step in producing the silicon at the heart of most panels is to melt silica rock at 3,000 degrees Fahrenheit using electricity, commonly from coal-fired power plants.”
Five years ago, Stanford researchers tell us, the solar industry consumed 75 percent more energy than it produced. Here’s the good news, from the same report:
“That irony, according to Stanford University researchers, is coming to an end.”
As technology advances, the report explains, the energy required to produce solar products may continue to go down as the efficiency of solar products improves. This is probably true, as technology typically makes our world cleaner, safer and more enjoyable.
Solar technology has great promise, and we hope it succeeds in contributing substantially to the energy humans need to continue advancing. Just as technological advancements constantly reduce the environmental stresses posed by oil, gas and coal, they may improve the environmental toll of solar panels.
In the meantime, facts do not support conventional wisdom that says solar panels — though expensive — are friendly to Mother Earth. At this juncture, they are not. Environmental activists, and a majority on the council, don’t seem to care.






