COMMUNITY FORUM: Memorial Hospital (2 pro, 3 con)
Physicians endorse lease
Physicians across Memorial Health System and throughout our community are supporting 1A, a plan that would allow our city to lease the hospital to University of Colorado Health. This plan provides an opportunity to not just continue the great care you receive today, but also to enhance that care with more choices, resources and support.
By passing 1A, we have the opportunity to create something great and enduring for the citizens of Colorado Springs. What is it? A Colorado-based health system, built on shared values, which incorporates the strengths of community care and academic medicine.
This newly formed health system will deliver many opportunities to improve the quality of health care for the citizens of Colorado Springs. This association will bring additional health care resources and jobs to our city, create the strength to attract, train, and retain high quality physicians in our community through creation of a medical education campus, and enhance our already robust pediatric and adult health care services. It will create economies of scale for purchasing and operations by leveraging the power of a large multihospital system. Additionally, it creates a regional referral center in our community for all of southern Colorado, western Kansas and northern New Mexico.
Finally, this lease will ensure we continue to have the financial wherewithal to provide top of the line services for our military service men and women, and our under served and indigent populations.
As we see it, this lease is the best alternative for Memorial Health System. Failure to approve this lease would be a calamity for the health system, the patients and the citizens of Colorado Springs. Now it is time for all of us to stand up and be counted. With your support, the passage of 1A on Aug. 28 will mark one of the greatest moments in the history of this community and we urge you to vote yes.
Karen Anthony, M.D., Chief of Staff,Robert Kiley, M.D., Chief of Staff-Elect,
Memorial Health System
Memorial must change
The best deal for health care in Colorado Springs was overlooked when city leaders eliminated the spin-off of Memorial Health System to a 501C3 (not-for-profit organization). The spinoff would have allowed for continued “local” control of Memorial, an inevitable partnership with the University and Poudre Valley of Northern Colorado, and collaboration with Penrose.
The problem at that time was the leadership at Memorial which could have been changed. So, we are offered the next best option. And, it is a great option! But unnamed individuals within this city don’t want it and are putting propaganda out there to make you believe Memorial Health System can remain as it is and always has been. It can’t!
Just like the Post Office cannot do business as it has in the past. Change happens and the way health care is going, Memorial will not survive under its current governance. Just what do those unnamed individuals want? They want the environment to be such that Colorado Springs will have no other choice than to let HealthOne come in and buy Memorial. If that happens, non-money making services will be taken to Denver (pediatrics, geriatrics, etc.).
If a loved one gets sick, we will either be driving the 1-25 corridor tired in the morning because we are worried and didn’t get a good night’s sleep or driving home exhausted because we’ve just spent the day with an ill child, parent or spouse and remain worried.
The choice is ours. Memorial Health System will never be what it was….time and changes have seen to that. But it can still take care of our indigent, kids, parents and us. And, if we have an illness that cannot be taken care of in Colorado Springs, we will have the opportunity to go to Denver to a world-class facility that most likely will no longer be “out of network” — the University of Colorado Hospital.
Please think before you vote. It isn’t a scam……it’s a great choice and we are lucky to have it on our table.
Ruth Snyder
Colorado Springs
What about insurance plans?
My wife and I are past and possibly future patients at Memorial Hospital. One of my concerns about the lease to University Health is what insurance plans they will accept and which ones they will not accept. I have not seen any information on this topic. There are variations of insurance plans that a hospital may or may not accept.
For example, from personal experience I know that Penrose accepts one insurance company’s regular plans, but not its senior advantage plan. If complete disclosure of insurance acceptance information is not made public soon, then I feel I must vote against approving the lease.
James Mahon
Colorado Springs
‘Before I vote yes’
We are being asked to approve the leasing of our hospital on the 28th of this month. What has our city council and the mayor done to provide controls on the use of the proceeds from the Memorial Hospital lease agreement ?
In the early discussion of what to do about the hospital the question of how to deal with the proceeds of a sale was a real problem. This was due, as I understand it, to the fact that the hospital belongs to the people of the city; and a state law requires that any proceeds from a sale of the hospital be set aside and used to serve the medical needs of the city residents.
I assume the lease option ,which I feel may be a good idea; was brought to the table to get around the problem of the state law. Before I vote yes on August 28 I want to know how the city will handle the monies generated. Will they be assigned to the general fund and blown away on Olympic signs on warehouses and the like, or will it be invested to benefit the residents of Colorado Springs?
Jon Daubert
Colorado Springs
Not much of a liability
I am voting no because of the lack of a valid reason to make a change.
There has been little, if no debate on the reason for change. However, there has been a lot of debate on which is the better deal concluding that change is necessary. Who woke up one morning and declared Memorial a liability? A $32 million unfunded liability (probably caused by the costs of expansion) is the usual stated reason. However, put that in perspective. $32 million is less than one tenth of Memorial’s current on hand cash which is $330 million. Not much of a liability to me. Besides, didn’t we have an election last year which limited our liability with Memorial Hospital? A real and looming liability is $61 million, if this plan passes. That is the difference between what PERA says is the employment pension buy out ($246 million) and the amount allowed by the proposed deal ($185 million) to pay for it.
What makes the city fathers think they can negotiate the $246M down to the $185M or less, other than their egos?
There is an organization spending a lot of money in support of the city council’s proposal, however, their motivations are unknown. I’m always leery when it comes to politics and large sums of citizens’ money. I smell a rat in this deal.
Might the real motivation for the deal be the $74 million up front money and $5.6 million a year coming into the city coffers with no fence around it or restrictions on how it may be spent. The crazy thing is that the proposed plan allows UC Health to take all of our on hand cash to pay us their debt.! This is one heck of a good deal….but not for the citizens.
I consider Memorial Hospital a valuable asset and the proposed deal appears to me to be giving it away. Memorial may continue to be an asset under the control of UC Health, but that is an unknown factor. As I understand the rules on enterprises, profits can not be moved from the enterprise to the city coffers, and for good reason. That must really perplex the city fathers, all that cash and they can’t get their hands on it.
It is possible the city considers the expensive PERA retirement, enjoyed by Memorial’s employees, to be a risky unfunded liability. Based on a required $185M to $246M buy-out, that may be true. Why not keep Memorial in the city and gradually withdraw from the retirement system using attrition? However, remember that Memorial has $330M cash on hand. That money could be used to convert retirement systems lump sum, if so desired.
Considering city council’s past poor record in managing utilities and Memorial, they may consider themselves completely incapable of proper management of such large enterprises, especially one staffed with highly educated individuals — who knows what lurks in the minds of politicians.
My bottom line is “show me the beef”. Show me a valid reason to make a change. Then, show me a plan that does not allow the buyer/leaser to rob the till (cash on hand) to pay off the politicians, spells out what is expected of the buyer/leaser to provide quality low-cost health service to our citizens, and, defines what specifically is to be done with any profits generated — then I’ll bite on it.
Del Reiss
Colorado Springs






