GUEST COLUMN: Education finance system fails to promote achievement
The time has come for Colorado to embrace an all-new approach to funding education that promotes a productive use of existing dollars to augment student learning success.
For nearly 20 years, the state has operated under the same basic School Finance Act. The legislation is the biggest cog in a funding machine that drives multiple pots of tax dollars into local school district coffers while demanding no results. Broad agreement exists that Colorado should change how we fund K-12 education. But more creative thinking and political courage are still needed.
On March 19, the State Board of Education convened education leaders and policymakers for a panel discussion with national school finance experts. Two panelists in particular — Stanford University’s Eric Hanushek and the University of Washington’s Marguerite Roza — shared a profound and promising vision for our state to pursue.
Funds should reward success rather than failure, a sensible practice that has escaped the designs of our current system. As Hanushek observed, “If the funds aren’t used effectively, and we know they aren’t in Colorado, then how do you possibly determine what it would take? Because it would be an infinite amount.”
Since 1970, Colorado and the nation at large have far more than doubled spending in real per-pupil dollars. Federal and state tax contributions have mushroomed. The system has grown increasingly expensive to run, without the extra student learning to show for it. Today our K-12 public schools receive more than $10,000 in annual tax revenue per student and lay out nearly as much on “current” operating expenses.
Recent economic woes have brought budget cutbacks to most Colorado school districts. And the long trend of steady, year-to-year increases in per-pupil funding does not appear ready to resume anytime soon. A struggling real estate market, competing state budget priorities and a federal debt crisis all loom over hopes for any significant K-12 revenue increases. We have to be creative and do things differently.
Last year, the School Finance Partnership met with the goal of crafting a vision for remolding our state’s education funding system. Months after a school funding study was presented as plaintiff’s evidence in Colorado’s Lobato lawsuit, part of the Partnership’s action plan is a further analysis of a new K-12 funding amount, “using a balance between all available methods.”
One of the most prevalent methods used in such analyses involves asking school administrators how much more money they would need. Another common approach compares the cost of running “successful school districts,” even though many local agencies do more with less — and vice versa.
The inevitable result will be a continuing drumbeat for massive amounts of additional funding. But Colorado voters last year registered a resounding “no” on the Proposition 103 education tax hike question.
While some of the Partnership’s proposed ideas are focused on solving the right challenges, it is time to take the school funding conversation in a bolder direction. Colorado needs to focus first and foremost on how we pay for student learning success, regardless of how that might affect existing adult interest groups.
The state should use its funding authority to persuade districts to pursue effective spending policies. A key example can be found in how we compensate teachers, an important function that comprises a significant share of K-12 operating budgets. Nearly 2 percent of operating dollars pay for educator “master’s bumps,” automatic salary increases that incentivize extra degree credentials. Research shows they have practically zero impact on student learning.
The logic and conclusions of the Colorado Expanded Learning Opportunities Commission has generated an array of student learning-driven ideas that will require alternate funding mechanisms.
Dollars ought not only to be tied to measurable performance gains but also to follow students based on their learning needs, even to the course level.
High school students should be able to use digital technology to blend their learning with a broad menu of online course options. A share of funds could be used to pay the chosen provider for successfully boosting the student’s learning.
Colorado has only begun to scratch the surface of ideas to create a truly portable, productive and performance-based system of school finance.
Paul Lundeen is a first-term member of the Colorado State Board of Education, elected to represent the state’s 5th congressional district.





