REVIEW: ‘Bully’ suggests no solution
There’s a fleeting shot in “Bully” of a kid who just plain looks mean. He has a cruel mouth and squinting eyes, and you wonder if he knows how to smile. The movie singles him out but says nothing about him. Is he one of the bullies? Who knows? He reminded me of a kid in grade school who called me Fatso. I called him Stupid. We were both right.
There’s only one bully actually identified in the film. A clueless teacher has pulled together two kids who got in a fight and insists they shake hands. One kid is as friendly as an insurance salesman, and sticks out his paw with a friendly smile. The other kid refuses. The teacher sends the friendly kid away and lectures the other one. Of course it’s the “nice kid” who is the bully. He probably gets away with more stuff than a con man. His victim knows it. He’s been down this path before.
If the teacher were more clued-in, she’d know it, too. One of the themes in Lee Hirsch’s documentary is how many parents and teachers have no idea what’s really happening in the secret society of children in their care. Many bullied children are reluctant to tell anyone what’s happening to them. Are they embarrassed, or scared? Bullying is designed to make them feel inferior, and in their cases, perhaps it has worked.
The film follows the stories of several children in Mississippi, Oklahoma, Iowa and Georgia. Two of them committed suicide. Their lives had become unendurable without anyone noticing, or taking it seriously enough. I can believe it. The most infuriating people in the film are teachers or administrators who don’t know what’s happening — or don’t want to know, perhaps afraid of bureaucratic difficulties or angry parents.
Sometimes an entire community gets in on the act. A girl who is a lesbian is humiliated by a teacher in front of other students, and her parents observe that many of their own friends of long standing have become hostile. A culture of ignorance and homophobia feeds this.
Much has been made of how the MPAA gave this film an R rating for its language. (A PG-13 has belatedly been handed out to a version with some words taken out.) It was widely said that the MPAA was preventing admission to those very kids under age 17 who could benefit from it the most. That part I’m not so sure about. The movie contains little solid information about bullying, and although we feel sorry for the victims who are profiled, it is unclear what can be learned from observing them. My notion is that a fictional film might be more effective than a documentary. It could encourage young viewers to identify with victims of bullying and dislike bullies.
Why are some people bullied? Because they are different. How? It doesn’t matter. A bully can act as the catalyst for encouraging a group to draw together in cruelty against someone perceived as not a member. This process was shown with great power in Larry Clark’s “Bully” (2001), which added an unexpected twist: A brutal bully is murdered by a group of his victims, who together are moved to do something none could do alone.
“Bully” is a sincere documentary, but not a great one. We feel sympathy for the victims and their parents or friends, but the film seems to helplessly treat bullying as a problem without a solution.
Racism and all the other -isms grow from primitive tribalism, the instinctive hostility against those of another tribe, race, religion, nationality, class or whatever. You are a lucky child if your parents taught you to accept diversity. Teaching prejudice to a child is itself a form of bullying. You’ve got to be taught to hate.
DETAILS
Grade: B
Cast: As themselves: Alex, Ja’Meya, Kelby, David Long, Tina Long, Kirk Smalley, Laura Smalley
Director: Lee Hirsch
Rated: No MPAA rating (a PG-13 version has some vulgarities removed)
Running time: 1 hour, 46 minutes
In this undated film image released by The Weinstein Company, Alex Libby is shown in the documentary film, “Bully.” The Weinstein Co. said the rating for “Bully” has been lowered from R to PG-13. The company announced Thursday that an edited version of the documentary with a PG-13 rating from the Motion Picture Association of America would be released April 13. (AP Photo/The Weinstein Company) Photo by





