Finger pushing
loader-image
weather icon 78°F


GO! DINING REVIEW: Pleasantville – Rosie’s Diner offers nice ’50s feel

I didn’t live through the 1950s. Not by a long shot. Still, I recognize all of the hot rod-driving, poodle skirt-wearing, jukeboxed and ponytailed stereotypes about the era when I see them.

Rosie’s Diner conjures that classic “American Graffiti” feel, with enough ’50s flair to outfit an episode of “Happy Days.”

Many folks probably remember Rosie’s from a Bounty quicker-picker-upper paper towel commercial. Clever entrepreneurs have built that brand into a successful Michigan-based chain that has one established location in Monument and a new one north of Colorado Springs.

Certainly, the colorful business is welcome in the still-underdeveloped area off Interquest Parkway in the Shops at Voyager. Although I found the food there to range from good and homey to a bit bland or oversalted, there’s a lot of it, and the restaurant’s counters certainly have that Bounty-clean shine to them.

 

Ambience

Unlike the metallic façade of our original Rosie’s, which reminds me of a classic Airstream trailer, this location is in the corner of a modern shopping complex. The interior is coated in red and black, including the comfy benches of the booths, and the walls are decked with black-and-white posters of America’s favorite icons: James Dean, Audrey Hepburn, Travolta and Newton-John in the movie “Grease.” A red truck outside and the front half of a black coupe acting as host stand complete the look.

However, the high ceilings and squeaky-clean newness of the joint lack the personality of the traditional American diner, in my opinion. While obviously done with care, I felt like the diner created a theme-park version of an already-idealized era. Of course, a visit to a theme park can sometimes be just the ticket for a family brunch or weekend outing.

 

Highlights

That Rosie’s doesn’t obsess about diner authenticity can be a good thing. It means that the often-greasy American classics sit side by side with brighter, contemporary options. For instance, one guest can order a big platter of runny, over-easy eggs served with kick-butt spicy Polish sausage and a flaky, warm, homemade biscuit ($7.99). (I love that the biscuits are served with honey in addition to butter.) Across the table, another patron might order the Aspen Fritatta ($8.25) with artichokes, pesto, olives, Parmesan and a grilled croissant.

Burgers ($7.99-$8.99) are a diner staple, and Rosie’s does them justice with a thick bun that holds up until the last bite and decent choice beef. Similarly, the classic tuna melt ($8.25) is supported with thick, tasty sourdough, and the Texas toast is crisp and thick compared with cheaper, low-quality breads.

The restaurant is devoted to hot and fresh, and that’s epitomized in the Cinnamon Supreme French Toast ($7.25). The toast is made from slices of cinnamon swirl bread, very pretty on the plate, and is served with whole slices of fresh melon and strawberries. Cold is also a good way to go at Rosie’s, and I thought the chocolate malt ($3.99) was slurp-to-the-last-drop delicious.

The ability to order what’s thought of as home-style, made-by-Mom meals is alluring. After all, there are few places outside Mom’s kitchen — or really any kitchen in this decade — where you can order liver and onions ($8.50). Also, the pot roast dinner ($8.99) was obviously given adequate time to slow-cook, the meat pulling apart into tender ribbons.

 

Bonuses

• Rosie’s offers buy-one-get-one-half-off to employees from certain companies on specific days of the week, including FedEx, Oracle, Progressive, Lockheed and more. Call for details.

• The headlights of the truck outside and the car/host stand light up at night, which is especially fun for the kids.

 

Drawbacks

That pot roast mentioned above arrived way oversalted, as did other dishes. The fried pickles, for example, were hot, crispy and released a great, meaty tang when I bit in, but left me with a salty thirst my vanilla Coke couldn’t cure.

The gravies were big culprits on that count. Both the pot roast’s brown gravy and the chicken-fried steak ($8.99) and its white gravy were very salty. I admit I was really looking forward to the chicken-fried steak, but though the crust was golden and crisp, the steak itself had little distinct beef flavor and tasted cafeterial to me.

While some eggs I ordered were nicely cooked, the scrambled eggs with the huevos Mexicanos ($7.99) were mealy, with a thick layer of jack cheese that quickly became plasticky. And even the Cinnamon French Toast, which I enjoyed, was more pretty than it was cinnamon-laced, and most of the flavor came from the syrup.

But, as you find in many successful chains, nothing I found would be labeled bad. Instead, my mind kept returning to the word “unobjectionable.”

 

Service

Servers wear Rosie’s Diner T-shirts, and the girls wear ribbons tied around their ponytails. They’re kind and attentive, and I was even given an unrequested free refill of a house-mixed vanilla Coke, which I had assumed would mean an upcharge.

Most of the servers, like me, were too young to have experienced the 1950s, but they have smiles that suit the scrubbed version of the decade that Rosie’s presents.

Overall, like most high-quality theme parks, the experience is designed to be happy and bright, and it’s an experience I enjoyed, even if the food hit few high notes.

Cinnamon Supreme French Toast Photo by PHOTOS BY KATE JONUSKA

Picasa 3.0

Eggs and sausage plate Photo by

Picasa 3.0

The menu is huge. Photo by

Picasa 3.0

Tags


Welcome Back.

Streak: 9 days i

Stories you've missed since your last login:

Stories you've saved for later:

Recommended stories based on your interests:

Edit my interests