How a teacher’s response to diversity affects students
In a country as culturally diverse as the United States, you can’t expect that every family eats pumpkin pie on Thanksgiving.
Yet in many elementary classrooms, a child who has never tasted pumpkin pie might get a startled reaction from a teacher who thinks the youngster is culturally deprived. That response, in turn, can make the child feel abnormal.
It was a simple example of how cultural — even regional — differences can make children feel like misfits in public schools and affect their academic achievement. But it brought home the message for teachers and counselors attending the 5th annual Culturally Responsive Teaching, Leadership and Counseling Symposium on Saturday at the University of Colorado at Colorado Springs. About 175 educators attended the free event.
A teacher’s response to differences among students is crucial to how well those students will perform, speakers said.
La Toyua Tolbert, an elementary program coordinator in the Cherry Creek School District, said far too often a child’s spirit is broken over things that have nothing to do with academic ability.
“Show me that what I bring is of value to you, and I will learn,” she said. “We all bring something of value to the table.”
Children know whether they’re in the “low” or the “high” reading group, and those labels can have significant impact on their learning, she said.
Philip Trejo, who led a session called “Why a Sense of Membership Matters in Addressing the Achievement Gap,” pointed out that study after study shows that in the work world, employees who feel they are valued and respected are more productive. Schoolchildren, he said, need the same things.
“Let’s talk to our kids,” said Trejo, principal of Monte Vista Middle School. “Let’s establish those relationships.
What’s the secret? There isn’t one. Just dare to care.”
Trejo emphasized that caring doesn’t mean becoming buddies with students and making life easy for them. High expectations produce higher achievement as long as students believe they’re being given a shot at success and are treated fairly, he said.
Geneva Gay, a University of Washington professor and expert on multicultural education, wrapped up the daylong symposium by challenging participants to push for culturally responsive teaching even though it will make others uncomfortable.
People don’t like change, she said, “because they fear the reallocation of knowledge and power.”
“I hear teachers say they are powerless to make change,” she said. “That’s not true. You have the power to affect the lives of children every day.”
DetailsClick for more information on Culturally Responsive Teaching, Leadership and Counseling programs at UCCS
Actor Brad Pitt waves to spectators before an NFL football divisional playoff game between the Arizona Cardinals and New Orleans Saints in New Orleans last week. Photo by THE ASSOCIATED PRESS





