Finger pushing
loader-image
weather icon 36°F


In a steak trimming contest, everyone makes the cut

Who said meat is a man thing?

Not Andrea Estrada, who went mano-o-mano against 10 other Texas Roadhouse restaurant meat cutters Monday, all of them male.

The competition, held on the ice in the frigid Colorado Sports Center in Monument, would see two cutters advance to semi-finals in January. The top six semi-finalists from about 320 restaurants around the country will wield their knives next spring in Manhattan, vying for the prize of top cutter and $20,000.

Estrada, who works at the Texas Roadhouse on 8th Street, didn’t have the experience of some of the other meet cutters she faced. She’s worked at the restaurants two years but has only spent several months in the 32-degree meat-cutting room honing her cutting skills.

Still, when the clock started ticking on the competition, she picked up her razor sharp knives and started methodically cutting her way — always against the grain — through multi-pound hunks of sirloin, rib-eye and filet.

The top two meat cutters would be the ones who wrung out the most and the highest quality steaks from the big blocks of meat. That meant no fat, except for a bit on sirloins to give them extra taste, no stringy nerves clinging to the meat and nice tapering — meaning the steaks were to be 1 inch to 1 1/4 inches thick, with a nice flat plane to aid grilling. The long hunk of filet given to each cutter, the most costly meat for the restaurant and for consumers, was the most difficult to cut correctly, starting with the delicate shearing off of a thin, tough membrane called silver skin.

Estrada, bundled up in seven shirts, three pants and two pair of socks — her normal work-day outfit — turned on her iPod, bent over her table and quietly began making cuts, throwing her trimmed steaks on a small scale to see if she had hit the target weight for the various cuts of meat.

Nearby, Willie Pitts, the meat-cutter for the Powers Boulevard Texas Roadhouse, added some showmanship, befitting a guy who has spent two years in the meat-cutting room. He gave Tiger Woods-like fist pumps when he deftly carved off sirloin steaks in the correct weights — 6, 8 , 11 and 16 ounces. He occasionally rapped a cutting board with his long carving knife to some internal rhythm, made a slight dance move, then bent low to caress the steaks into perfect shapes.

Elsewhere on the ice, some meat-cutters shunned the limelight and chose not to talk. One guy from Pueblo cut in short sleeves, with piercings through his lower lip.

The meat-cutters are generally an odd lot, most of them reserved, all of them capable of spending an entire shift alone in arctic-like conditions, said John Beck, who runs six restaurants in the Denver area. Beck said the meat-cutters are typically the highest-paid workers in the restaurant, and good ones are highly prized in a chain that makes its money and stakes its reputation on good steaks.

“Our restaurants have meat display boxes, and most of them show the name of the meat cutter,” he said. “We like to show off a little bit.”

In the end, after the quality and quantity of steaks were judged by two restaurant-chain coaches, a cutter from Longmont emerged the winner, followed by one from Arvada.

Neither Estrada nor Pitts were too cut up over the results.

“I gave my best,” said Pitts. “I can leave with my head up.”

Estrada said she had some problems carving up the rib-eye — an “ugly piece of meat.”

Still, she’s not deterred. For a one-time vegetarian who later became a broil cook at the restaurant, she reckons she’s come a long way in a short time.

“I can cook a damn good steak,” she said. “Now I need to learn how to cut them.

“I like jobs chicks don’t like to do.”

Photo by

Tags news related


Welcome Back.

Streak: 9 days i

Stories you've missed since your last login:

Stories you've saved for later:

Recommended stories based on your interests:

Edit my interests