Accused killer claims innocence in opening arguments
Ryan Krueger claims he is innocent in the 2001 murder of 19-year-old college student Patricia Ann Elliott.
Prosecutors cut a deal with the real killer, Benjamin Gunvalsen, who incriminated Kreuger through a series of selfish lies, argued Krueger, 31, in opening statements in his second trial Wednesday.
“They made this deal because the Elliott family needed resolution,” Krueger told the jury. “But closure sacrifices truth.”
The argument worked for Krueger before. Chief 4th Judicial District Judge Kirk Samelson declared a mistrial after Krueger’s first trial in May when jurors could not agree on a verdict after almost 20 hours of deliberations over three days.
Krueger is charged with the 2001 murder of Elliott, a University of Colorado at Colorado Springs freshman, who was strangled and bludgened with a barbell in her off-campus townhouse.
Krueger planned the murder, enlisting the help of co-defendents Christopher Allen and Gunvalsen, because he suspected Elliott was a snitch in their drug dealings, said Chief Deputy District Attorney Gail Warkentin in her opening statement.
Police and prosecutors say that Elliott had been dealing drugs that she purchased from the three men.
But “life is not a Sopranos episode,” said Krueger, who argued that Elliott was killed by Gunvalsen because of greed, not because he thought she was a snitch.
“The inconvenient truth is that (Gunvalsen) killed Patricia Elliot,” said Krueger, and in exchange for his testomony “(was) given a get out of jail free card.”
Gunvalsen made a deal with prosecutors in 2005 and is serving time on accessory charges in exchange for testimony against Krueger and Allen.
Earlier this year, Allen, 29, was convicted of first-degree murder and is serving life in prison. He refused to testify in Krueger’s first trial, citing his 5th Amendment rights against self-incrimination.
“My DNA wasn’t there (at the murder scene) because I wasn’t there,” Krueger told the jury.
At that point, Senior Deputy District Attorney Margaret Vellar objected to Krueger introducing evidence in opening statements.
Samelson warned the jury that opening statements are not to be taken as actual evidence, but merely an outline of the case to come.
Still, Krueger continued to instruct the jury to be aware of what he considers inconsistancies in Gunvalsen’s testimony.”(Gunvalsen) won’t remember times and places; he’ll only remember those things that he wants you to hear,” Krueger said.
Krueger is defending himself against the first-degree murder charge, and could face life in prison without parole if convicted. He is being held in El Paso County Jail without bond.
Photo by





