Two sides to state Sen. Dave Schultheis
DENVER – Dave Schultheis finished third in his weekend bid to be Colorado’s Republican National Committeeman, getting trounced by former Senate Majority Leader Mark Hillman and snagging fewer votes than little-known activist Leondray Gholston.Though the race went largely unnoticed, the results speak to the conundrum that is the Colorado Springs state senator. Universally praised by those who know him as one of the nicest, most genuine people in the General Assembly, Schultheis is defined to many by his divisive stands on issues and his sometimes acerbic rhetoric.Rep. Mike Merrifield, a Colorado Springs Democrat who lost a race to Schultheis in 2000 and since has served for six years in the Legislature with him, says he is very “black and white.” Schultheis is the kind of person who was supportive of him personally as he battled throat cancer, yet can be “hateful” in his views on issues, he said.”As a person, he can be very pleasant,” Merrifield said. “But if you debate him on policy, he’s like a different person. He’s like Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde.”Schultheis does not dispute the impression people may get from the fierce stands he takes against abortion or illegal immigration. But he won’t change the way he approaches issues to win popularity.”I don’t know how to change the perception of people,” the 67-year-old rental-property owner said.
“The only thing I take from that is that if you take any kind of strong, principled stand, people think you’re an ogre. And I don’t think there’s anything you can do about that.”The stand that he is revered and reviled for is his desire to close America’s southern border to illegal immigration. His passion for the subject led him to patrol the border with an activist group and propose numerous failed bills against illegal immigrants.It led to what many consider the biggest black mark on his record: His e-mail to the Greeley Tribune in 2006 asking why the paper did not question the immigration status of a Hispanic family involved in a fatal car crash. The family of U.S. citizens blasted the correspondence as insensitive and said he picked them out because of their surname.Schultheis said his questions about the cost of illegal immigrants on societal services remain valid, and he hates being labeled by that one illtimed e-mail.Gil Cisneros, chairman of the Colorado National Republican Hispanic Assembly, said such instances led him to campaign openly against Schultheis for the national committeeman position, which essentially serves as the state’s voice to the national party. He lamented that Schultheis has refused invitations to meet with his group; Schultheis responded that he wouldn’t speak to a group that doesn’t have an open mind.But there’s much more to Schultheis, said Rep. Kevin Lundberg, a Berthoud Republican who collaborates with the senator politically and has spent time with Schultheis and Sandra, his wife of 46 years. Lundberg admires the close relationship Schultheis has with his two daughters and five grandchildren and says his care for issues rather than his desire to score political points has caricatured the senator when it should have elevated him.Schultheis is one of the most soft-spoken, self-effacing senators, often laughing at himself as he presents bills and rarely taking to the floor to grandstand.Republican cohorts razz him playfully for his constant “no” votes, yet Senate GOP Caucus Chairman Mike Kopp, R-Littleton, said plainly: “This is a good man.””He is a hero,” said Sen. Scott Renfroe, R-Greeley. “He is a person I look up to every single day we’re there.”Even polar political opposites don’t treat him like a demon. When Schultheis flinched as Democratic Sen. Betty Boyd of Lakewood came to the microphone to speak on one of his bills this year, Boyd responded: “Don’t be scared. This is a good bill.”Rep. Rosemary Marshall, a black Denver Democrat, called Schultheis a racist during a testy confrontation on the floor several years ago. But Schultheis wrote Marshall what he called a heart-felt sympathy card when her sister died a year later. Marshall, when asked about Schultheis recently, said: “He’s always been gracious and a gentleman.”Schultheis has taken to watching out for the most polarizing member of the Legislature: Rep. Douglas Bruce, R-Colorado Springs. He has chided some of Bruce’s fellow House Republicans to treat him more like the Christians they espouse to be, and he and Sandra try to dine with Bruce once a week and offer him friendship.Yet, at Saturday’s convention, one of the striking contrasts was the roughly 40 party movers and shakers who joined Hillman on stage during his speech versus the two backers who joined Schultheis and his wife on stage.Friend to many who know him, enigma to many who don’t, Schultheis remains the staunch, passionately conservative fighter he has always tried to be, like him or not.”I want to be known as ending well, where you look back on your life and say: ‘I feel I’ve done what’s right . . . where I’ve been as kind and generous to people as I can be . . . where I’ve had a high degree of integrity . . . where people can say: ‘He didn’t waver from what he knew was right.'”CONTACT THE WRITER: (303) 837-0613 or ed.sealover@gazettedev.gazette.com.
Luke Myers Photo by The Gazette/Kirk Speer





