Finger pushing
loader-image
weather icon 47°F


No photo to vote, for now

   DENVER – You may need a driver’s license to get a beer, but you don’t need one to get a ballot.   When voters go to the polls this year, they will be able to show they’re eligible to vote by presenting a copy of their birth certificate, pay stub or utility bill.   The Legislature has debated whether Colorado needs stricter standards, and the parties are split on the issue. Republicans say they’re defending the integrity of the election process. Democrats say they’re defending citizens’ fundamental rights.   The issue for those who think laws need to be tightened is voter fraud – in which someone is able to vote more than once – or illegal immigrants being able to cast votes.   Last Monday, the U.S. Supreme Court weighed in on the matter, saying in a 6-3 ruling that states can require voters to present photo identification before being allowed to vote.   Though the decision won’t affect the 2008 election in Colorado, it is the latest chapter in an ongoing feud between Democrats and Republicans over how hard it should be to cast a ballot.   House Republicans backed a bill earlier this session requiring a voter to provide photo identification before getting a ballot. The measure was killed on a party-line vote in a House committee.   The bill’s opponents said that courts were still debating the constitutionality of a similar law in Indiana. The Supreme Court’s decision in the Indiana case, Crawford v. Marion County Election Board, has resolved that issue, and now Republicans are claiming vindication.   “The Supreme Court has reaffirmed what we’ve been saying all along,” said Rep. Frank McNulty, R-Highlands Ranch. “States have an obligation to make sure people allowed to vote are who they say they are.”   Tightening the law is just common sense, said El Paso County Clerk Bob Balink, a Republican.   “The bottom line is if we have laws on eligibility, we ought to be able in good faith to enforce those laws,” Balink said.   Democrats don’t disagree with that. They just don’t believe Republicans are acting in good faith.   “It’s a planned political strategy,” Senate Majority Leader Ken Gordon said. Studies have shown the proposed changes would mostly affect the elderly, the poor and minorities, the Denver Democrat said. People in those categories tend to vote for Democrats, and he doesn’t think the GOP would pursue the issue if it were the other way.   The problems are exaggerated to push unneeded solutions, Gordon said.   “No one has ever found, that I know of, a conspiracy,” he said. “There’s a paranoid fantasy that seems to be out there, and there’s no evidence of it because it’s not true.”   The Supreme Court decision acknowledged the authors of the Indiana law had not demonstrated people were using forged documents to obtain ballots. However, it determined the threat was enough to justify the law.   Republicans like Balink deny it’s about politics.   “Elections are about politics. Election processes never should be,” he said.   Balink pointed to bills sponsored by Gordon that he says make it easier to vote fraudulently, including one that would let voters change their registrations online.   Prominent nonpartisan activist groups have mostly agreed with Democrats in opposing stricter identification laws. Common Cause and the League of Women Voters testified against Mc-Nulty’s bill when it was reviewed by the House committee.   “We want voting to be as easy as possible for the most registered voters,” said Carol Tone, who monitors voting law for the League of Women Voters. It says the laws will prevent the elderly and the poor from voting because they are less likely to have identification.   For some it is too costly, while others may have been born before governments required hospitals to issue birth certificates, they say.

Vivian Chow Photo by

Tags news


Welcome Back.

Streak: 9 days i

Stories you've missed since your last login:

Stories you've saved for later:

Recommended stories based on your interests:

Edit my interests