Finger pushing
loader-image
weather icon 34°F


Older students have no interest in CSAPs

DENVER – All it took to end years of bitter accusations and political fights between education reformers was a bunch of bored kids.That was the consensus among education experts Friday after the Senate overwhelmingly voted to approve a bill to drop the Colorado Student Assessment Program test from the state’s high school curriculum. It goes to the House for consideration.Liberal and conservative reformers acknowledged that many high school students don’t put much effort into the exam. Instead of trying their best, students would doodle and draw patterns on their answer sheets while sitting through multiple-hour exams.”Beyond the middle school grades, kids don’t take the CSAP seriously. The older the child, the less interest,” said Jeanne Beyer, spokeswoman for the Colorado Education Association.The reason is apparent: the CSAP has no bearing on college preparation or admission, and it doesn’t affect a student’s grade, say advocates for dropping it.”In the upper grades the kids don’t have an investment in it,” said former Rep. Dorothy Gottlieb, a Republican from Denver who was a high-ranking official in the Department of Education during Gov. Bill Owens’ administration.Students’ reaction to another required exam is markedly different. Every junior takes the ACT, which is used by colleges when considering which students to admit. There’s no shortage of investment in the results of that test.”These high school kids are hip to what really matters to them,” said Sen. Josh Penry, R-Grand Junction.Penry has been a solid backer of CSAP, and he remains committed to performance testing. But like an increasing number of Republicans, he is willing to try something different.”To push something of this scope, you need a coalition of supporters,” he said.Penry and Chris Romer, D-Denver, sponsored the bill (SB212) in the Senate. Rob Witwer, R-Golden, and Christine Scanlan, D-Dillon, are carrying it in the House.Republicans supporting the measure joined their frequent adversaries in the teachers union. They have doubted the effectiveness of CSAP since it was introduced in 1995, Beyer said, and disagreements over its importance and implementation have sparked bitter fights between lawmakers and advocates.But as time passed, they started to agree that high schoolers weren’t trying, and no accountability system would work if students don’t care.”There’s universal agreement that the CSAP at the high school level doesn’t help kids or guide them to the success they need in a post-secondary education environment,” Scanlan said.The idea of ditching CSAP for high school students has been floating around since last year. A commission appointed by Gov. Bill Ritter to do a comprehensive review of the education system recommended last fall that the change be made. Rep. Judy Solano, D-Brighton, introduced a bill early in the session that would have made the ACT the only statewide test for high school students, but the bill hasn’t advanced.But the biggest shift came recently when conservative educational reformers backed away from the CSAP. Penry said discussions with former Republican legislators and officials from the Owens administration resulted in “tremendous support for using the ACT as an assessment tool.”Beyer said a number of polls of union members showed strong support for the change, and the union was happy to back the proposal.Although the bill doesn’t commit the state to switching to the ACT, it would be a logical choice. High school students are familiar with the exam. Conservatives, including Penry, like its rigor, while teachers like the way it allows them to compare students to their peers around the nation. The results also come back much quicker, allowing teachers to be more responsive to students’ needs.Teachers and parents will also be able to track progress as a student moves from the pre-ACT tests in the ninth and 10th grades to the ACT itself.If the proposal becomes law, the elimination of CSAP would go into effect in a couple of years. The Legislature would still have to determine whether the ACT or another test would replace it.The proposal has led to a broad if unusual coalition. Its members hope it will last.”There’s so much political baggage and hostility over ‘the accountability wars’ that by itself creating a consensus approach is hugely important,” Penry said.One stumbling block may be how students in third through eighth grades are tested. The CSAPs for those grades will be rewritten once the Department of Education finishes upgrading the model content standards used around the state. There has been little discussion so far of what major changes may result.

Tags news


Welcome Back.

Streak: 9 days i

Stories you've missed since your last login:

Stories you've saved for later:

Recommended stories based on your interests:

Edit my interests